How to Navigate the IRS Offer in Compromise Process
A comprehensive guide to successfully settling your tax debt through the IRS Fresh Start initiative
If you're drowning in tax debt, the IRS Offer in Compromise (OIC) program might be your lifeline. I've watched friends and clients navigate this process—some successfully settling $50,000+ debts for pennies on the dollar, others getting rejected due to simple mistakes. The difference? Consistent, systematic follow-through on every requirement.
The OIC process isn't quick or easy, but it's one of the few legitimate ways to settle tax debt for less than you owe. This guide walks you through every step, from initial qualification to final settlement, with accountability strategies that dramatically increase your approval odds.
What is an Offer in Compromise?
An Offer in Compromise is an IRS program that allows taxpayers to settle their tax debt for less than the full amount owed. The IRS accepts OIC applications when they determine the amount offered represents the most they can reasonably collect from you.
The IRS Fresh Start initiative (launched 2011, expanded 2012) made OIC more accessible by:
- Increasing the income threshold for qualification
- Allowing taxpayers to repay student loans and other allowable expenses
- Reducing the future income multiplier from 4-5 years to 1-2 years
Do You Qualify? The 4 Key Requirements
1. All Tax Returns Filed
You must have filed all required tax returns. Missing even one year disqualifies you immediately. This is non-negotiable.
2. Current Year Payments Made
You must have made all required estimated tax payments for the current year and made all required federal tax deposits if you own a business with employees.
3. Not in Active Bankruptcy
You cannot be in an open bankruptcy proceeding. The IRS won't negotiate while you're under bankruptcy protection.
4. Reasonable Collection Potential (RCP)
Your offer must equal or exceed your Reasonable Collection Potential—the IRS's calculation of what they could collect from your assets and future income.
The OIC Process: 8 Critical Steps
Pre-Qualify with Form 656-B
Use the IRS's Offer in Compromise Pre-Qualifier tool to determine if you're eligible before spending time on the full application.
Timeline: 30 minutes | Success Rate Impact: High
Gather Financial Documentation
Collect 3 months of: bank statements, pay stubs, investment statements, asset valuations, monthly expenses, and debt documentation.
Required Documents Checklist:
- ✓ Last 3 months bank statements (all accounts)
- ✓ Most recent pay stubs or income documentation
- ✓ Current mortgage/rent statements
- ✓ Vehicle registration and loan info
- ✓ Retirement account statements
- ✓ Business financial statements (if applicable)
Timeline: 1-2 weeks | Common Failure Point: Missing documents
Calculate Your Reasonable Collection Potential (RCP)
Formula: RCP = (Equity in Assets) + (Future Income × 12 or 24 months)
Your offer must be at least equal to your RCP. The IRS uses Form 433-A (individuals) or 433-B (businesses) to calculate this.
Timeline: 2-3 days | Common Mistake: Underestimating asset equity
Complete Form 656 (Offer in Compromise)
This is the main application form. You'll specify your offer amount and payment terms (lump sum or periodic payment).
Critical: Choose Your Payment Option
- Lump Sum: Pay 20% upfront + balance within 5 months (future income × 12 months)
- Periodic Payment: Pay first installment with application + monthly payments over 6-24 months (future income × 24 months)
Timeline: 2-4 hours | Pro Tip: Lump sum offers process faster
Submit Form 433-A or 433-B (Financial Statement)
This form provides detailed information about your income, expenses, assets, and liabilities. The IRS uses this to verify your RCP calculation.
Timeline: 3-5 hours | Common Failure: Inconsistent data with Form 656
Pay Application Fee + Initial Payment
$205 application fee (waived if you qualify as low-income) + 20% of offer (lump sum) or first installment (periodic payment).
Warning: Non-Refundable
Initial payments and application fees are non-refundable if your offer is rejected. The IRS applies payments to your tax debt.
Timeline: Same day | Critical: Don't skip this or application won't be processed
Mail Complete Package to IRS
Send everything certified mail with return receipt. The IRS has two processing centers depending on your state.
Timeline: 1 day | Pro Tip: Keep copies of EVERYTHING
Wait for IRS Review (6-12 months)
The IRS will review your application and may request additional documentation. During this time, collection activity is suspended.
During Review Period, You Must:
- ✓ File all tax returns on time
- ✓ Pay all current year taxes in full
- ✓ Continue periodic payments if you chose that option
- ✓ Respond to IRS requests within deadlines (usually 10-30 days)
Timeline: 6-12 months | Approval Rate: ~40% (higher with professional help)
7 Mistakes That Get OIC Applications Rejected
- 1. Missing unfiled returns: The #1 reason for rejection. File EVERYTHING before applying.
- 2. Undervaluing assets: The IRS will verify your asset values. Lying = automatic rejection.
- 3. Overestimating allowable expenses: The IRS uses standardized expense tables. Your actual expenses don't always matter.
- 4. Missing deadlines during review: The IRS gives you 10-30 days to respond to requests. Miss one = rejection.
- 5. Not staying current during review: If you miss a current year payment or filing, your offer is automatically withdrawn.
- 6. Offering too little: Your offer must meet or exceed your RCP. Lowball offers waste everyone's time.
- 7. Inconsistent information: Forms 656 and 433 must match. The IRS cross-checks everything.
How FreshStart Increases Your OIC Approval Odds
The OIC process takes 12-18 months from start to finish. Most rejections happen because taxpayers lose track of deadlines, miss documentation requests, or fall behind on current year obligations. FreshStart gives you daily accountability to stay on track.
📅 Track Critical Deadlines
Set commitments for quarterly estimated tax payments, document submission deadlines, and IRS response windows. Get daily SMS reminders so nothing falls through the cracks.
📄 Stay Current on Filings
Commit to filing all required returns and making current year payments. FreshStart checks in mid-day to ensure you're on track—before you forget at 11:59 PM on tax day.
🎯 Maintain Payment Consistency
If you chose periodic payments, commit to making each monthly installment on time. FreshStart helps you build the consistency the IRS requires to approve your offer.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does an Offer in Compromise cost?
$205 application fee (waived for low-income) + 20% of your offer amount upfront (lump sum) or first installment (periodic). If rejected, payments are applied to your tax debt.
What is the IRS acceptance rate for OIC?
Approximately 40% of OIC applications are accepted. Approval rates are higher when working with tax professionals and maintaining perfect compliance during the review period.
Can I submit an OIC if I'm making payments on an installment agreement?
Yes, but your installment agreement will be terminated when you submit the OIC. If your offer is rejected, you'll need to set up a new payment plan.
How long does the OIC process take?
6-12 months for IRS review, but the entire process from gathering documents to final approval typically takes 12-18 months.
What happens if my OIC is rejected?
You can appeal the decision within 30 days or submit a new offer with updated information. Initial payments are applied to your tax debt and are non-refundable.
Should I hire a tax professional for my OIC?
If you owe $20,000+, yes. Tax professionals (CPAs, Enrolled Agents, tax attorneys) have 60-70% approval rates vs. 40% for DIY applications. They understand IRS procedures and can negotiate effectively.
Related Fresh Start Guides
Ready to Settle Your Tax Debt?
FreshStart gives you daily accountability to stay on track through every step of the OIC process.
Start 14-Day Free Trial